The Top 5 Most Expensive Sports Cards Sold on eBay Last Week (March 2–8, 2025)
The trading card market remains hotter than ever, with collectors and investors spending big on rare and historic cards. Whether it’s modern rookie cards of future superstars or vintage legends from the past, eBay continues to be a battleground for high-stakes auctions. Last week saw some jaw-dropping sales, with several cards surpassing the five-figure mark. Let’s take a closer look at the top five biggest trading card sales from the past week.
1. 2024 Panini Prizm Jayden Daniels Gold Vinyl 1/5 (PSA 9) – $45,000
Sold on Friday, March 7
The biggest sale of the week belongs to Jayden Daniels, the electrifying quarterback prospect who led the Washington Commanders to their first NFC championship game since January 1992. Yes, you read that right. It's been a long. He couldn't get them past the Eagles into the Super Bowl — but still very impressive for a rookie.
This 2024 Panini Prizm Gold Vinyl parallel, limited to just five copies, commanded an astonishing $45,000 on eBay. The Gold Vinyl parallels are among the rarest and most sought-after versions of Prizm rookie cards, with their eye-catching gold finish and extreme scarcity making them a favorite among high-end collectors.
A PSA 9 grade ensures that this card is in near-mint condition, which is especially critical for modern cards where perfection is expected. As Daniels continues to generate buzz heading into his second season, investors are paying premium prices for his best rookie cards, hoping he will translate an amazing first year into superstardom. If he lives up to the hype, this could end up being a bargain in the long run. But, if he becomes the next RGIII, it could also be a costly gamble. That’s the thrill of prospecting in the sports card world!
2. Star 1984 Michael Jordan #101 Rookie Card (PSA 5) – $24,623
Sold on Thursday, March 6
Michael Jordan’s 1984 Star #101 card remains one of the most significant and debated basketball cards ever produced. Unlike his 1986 Fleer rookie, which is widely considered his official rookie card, the 1984 Star was actually the first card issued while Jordan was an NBA player. This card has a fascinating history, as it was part of a team set distributed directly through the Bulls rather than in traditional card packs, leading to its rarity and controversy in the collecting world.
This particular copy, graded PSA 5, sold for an impressive $24,623, demonstrating that demand for Jordan cards remains as strong as ever. While the grade isn’t particularly high, even lower-grade copies of this card command a premium due to its historical importance. With Jordan still being the face of basketball collectibles, it’s no surprise that his early cards continue to see strong sales. As more collectors recognize the 1984 Star as a true rookie card, prices may continue to climb over time.
3. 2000 Leaf Limited Tom Brady Limited Edition /50 (PSA 9) – $27,000
Sold on Friday, March 7
Tom Brady’s rookie cards have always been among the most valuable in football, and this 2000 Leaf Limited parallel, numbered to just 50 copies, is no exception. Selling for an impressive $27,000, this PSA 9-graded card is one of Brady’s rarest rookie issues, making it a prized possession for serious collectors. With only 50 copies in existence, finding one in near-mint condition is extremely difficult, which is why this card commanded such a high price.
Brady’s legacy as the greatest quarterback of all time continues to drive demand for his rookie cards, especially limited-edition versions like this one. The 2000 Leaf Limited set wasn’t as widely collected as some of his other rookie-year releases, but that only adds to its scarcity and appeal. As Brady’s influence on the game continues to grow, it’s likely that high-end collectors will continue paying top dollar for his best cards, ensuring their long-term value.
4. 2024 Topps Chrome Caleb Williams 1/1 – $20,000
Sold on Tuesday, March 4
Caleb Williams is already making waves in the sports card world, and he hasn’t even accomplished anything yet (besides seeing his coach get fired). This 2024 Topps Chrome 1/1 parallel, a true one-of-a-kind card, sold for a whopping $20,000, signaling just how high expectations are for the likely No. 1 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. With its bold refractor finish and unique 1/1 serial number, this card is a dream piece for any serious football collector.
Williams has drawn comparisons to Patrick Mahomes due to his exceptional arm talent and ability to extend plays, making him one of the most exciting quarterback prospects in recent memory. That hasn't played out on the field yet, but Troy Aikman wasn't very good his first season either — and he won three Super Bowls. Investors are still pouring money into Williams' rookie cards, hoping they’ll skyrocket in value if he lives up to the hype. While investing in unproven players is always risky, history has shown that if Williams turns into a franchise quarterback, this card could be worth significantly more in the future.
5. 1948 Leaf Baseball #98 Hal Newhouser (PSA 6) – $11,500
Sold on Saturday, March 8
Vintage baseball remains a cornerstone of the trading card market, and this 1948 Leaf Hal Newhouser card is a prime example of why collectors continue to chase classic pieces. Selling for $11,500, this PSA 6-graded card showcases one of the best pitchers of the 1940s, who was a two-time MVP and a Hall of Famer. The 1948 Leaf set is known for its bold colors and historic significance, being one of the first post-war baseball card sets ever produced.
Finding a 1948 Leaf card in solid condition is no easy task. Many of these cards suffer from printing defects, off-centering, and overall wear due to their age. A PSA 6 grade makes this copy a strong example, with sharp coloring and solid eye appeal. For vintage collectors, owning a well-preserved piece from one of baseball’s golden eras is a point of pride, and this sale reinforces the enduring demand for pre-1950s Hall of Fame cards.
Would You Drop $48k on a Card?
Last week’s biggest eBay sales highlight the diversity of the trading card market, from ultra-modern football prospects to legendary figures from baseball’s past. Whether you’re an investor looking for the next big thing or a collector chasing nostalgia, there’s never been a better time to be in the hobby.
What do you think about these sales? Would you drop $45,000 on a Jayden Daniels rookie card? Let us know in the comments!