The Top 5 Most Expensive Sports Cards Sold on eBay Last Week (April 13 – April 19, 2025)
Another week, another round of jaw-dropping cardboard sales on eBay — and this one was a beauty. From a red-hot rookie making history in the women’s game to a golden QB prospect, a vintage Nolan Ryan grail, and some of the most iconic basketball rookies ever printed, the market once again proved that nostalgia, rarity, and pure star power still reign supreme.
Here are the top five most expensive trading card sales on eBay for the week of April 13 to April 19.
1. 2024 Panini Prizm Drake Maye Rookie True Gold 3/10 (RC) PSA 9 – $35,000
Sold on Friday, April 18
Quarterback fever is in full swing ahead of the NFL Draft, and this golden stunner of Drake Maye, numbered to just 10 copies, sold for a staggering $35,000.
Graded a PSA 9, this “True Gold” parallel from 2024 Panini Prizm marks one of the earliest premium cards of the highly touted UNC star. As teams gear up to reshape their future under center, collectors are betting big on Maye becoming a franchise QB. True Gold Prizms are considered the grail tier of modern rookie cards, and this sale shows just how fast the market is moving — especially for cards that combine scarcity, hype, and potential.
If Maye lives up to the buzz, this might look like a steal a few years down the line.
2. Caitlin Clark Gold Cracked Ice 1/1 “Breaking 43-Year Women’s Scoring Record” – $15,000
Sold on Tuesday, April 15
The Caitlin Clark effect is very real.
This 1-of-1 Gold Cracked Ice card commemorating Clark’s NCAA career scoring record shattered the week’s expectations, closing at $15,000. It’s no surprise — Clark’s rise has been meteoric, captivating fans and bringing new energy (and collectors) to the women’s game.
The card doesn’t just celebrate a player; it celebrates a moment — one that rewrote the record books and redefined what women’s basketball can be. With WNBA buzz building and her stardom still rising, this sale reflects both current demand and long-term belief in Clark’s place in sports history.
A one-of-a-kind card for a one-of-a-kind player.
3. 1980 Topps Larry Bird / Magic Johnson Rookie Card (PSA 9) – $13,300
Sold on Sunday, April 13
Few cards in the hobby carry the weight — and dual-star power — of the 1980 Topps Bird/Magic rookie. Add in a strong PSA 9 grade, and it’s no surprise this beauty fetched $13,300.
With both Larry Bird and Magic Johnson sharing their rookie cardboard alongside Dr. J, this is one of the most iconic and instantly recognizable basketball cards ever produced. PSA 9s remain highly sought-after, with values continuing to climb as younger collectors and vintage fans alike recognize the cultural significance of this trio.
It’s a card that represents a turning point in basketball history — and it still turns heads over 40 years later.
4. 1961 Fleer Jerry West Rookie Card #43 (PSA 8) – $12,250
Sold on Wednesday, April 16
The man on the NBA logo still commands serious respect — and serious dollars.
This 1961 Fleer Jerry West rookie, graded PSA 8, brought in $12,250 on eBay this week. With sharp corners and excellent eye appeal, it’s easy to see why collectors chased it. Fleer’s ‘61 set is among the most iconic vintage basketball releases, and Jerry West — already a legend — has only grown in stature through his long and influential post-playing career.
High-grade examples like this don’t surface often, and when they do, they’re scooped up quickly by collectors who know exactly what they’re looking at.
5. 1968 Topps / O-Pee-Chee Nolan Ryan Rookie Card #177 (AGS 9) – $12,211
Sold on Saturday, April 19
Few rookie cards scream baseball royalty louder than Nolan Ryan’s 1968 Topps/O-Pee-Chee. This week, a mint AGS 9-graded OPC version sold for $12,211, showing that Ryan’s legacy still packs heat.
The O-Pee-Chee version — printed in Canada and often tougher to find in high grades — adds an extra layer of rarity to an already iconic card. Ryan’s early Mets days, his record-shattering strikeout totals, and his cult status with multiple franchises make this a cornerstone piece for vintage collectors.
Whether you're chasing no-hitters or just love that classic burlap border, this sale proves The Ryan Express still rolls strong.
Final Thoughts: A Week of Legends, Records, and Rising Stars
This week’s top sales spanned every era — from 1960s icons to the next generation of NFL and WNBA superstars. Whether you collect vintage staples or modern heat, the market is thriving with stories, moments, and milestones.
What’s your dream pull — a logo-minted Jerry West or a Gold Prizm QB of tomorrow? Let us know what grails you’re chasing, and check back next week for the next round of hobby heat.